|    Register
 
Sunday, May 11, 2008
Forum
SearchForum Home
     
  Public Discussions  General Babble  Yo Will, chapte...
 Yo Will, chapter 26.
 
 5/5/2008 12:01:10 AM
Chase
5 posts


Yo Will, chapter 26.
I remembered what you said on Wednesday, I meant to contact you through Lotro, but you weren't on when I was, so here.

After a little rumaging, I found chapter 26, which says "The Heavy is the root of light", and "The master stays rooted in all things". From a fencing perspective, it initially seems like the chapter teaches counterproductivity, when footwork is considered so important, but moreso, I think the chapter emphasizes not doing needless movement, like bouncing or moving around when little is happening in the bout. All movement should be purposeful and consise, so that I don't need to move any more or less. As I heard you say once, "nobody ever got hit because they were too far away", so I should keep a steady, safe distance from my opponent, and move in only when they present the opprotunity. Overall, my actions should be dictated by my opponent, when they advance, I retreat, when they retreat, I advance, like leader-follower, and I should use the energy to strike only when they present an opening for me. Anything else is needless movement that has a better chance of losing than winning.

Was I close?

I'm pretty.
 5/5/2008 2:15:14 PM
jscanlon
169 posts
5th


Re: Yo Will, chapter 26.

Chase, I know you are looking for Will's opinion but since you posted it here... :)  I would agree that all movement should have purpose but I don't think only using a reaction based strategy will work either.  It may for a touch or two but a better fencer will pick up on it and exploit it.  I think movement with purpose applies equally to being defensive as it does offensive.  Use movement to either counter act your opponents movement as you have described above or setup your offensive action or counter action.  Whenever we fence I often talking about exploiting gaps that people leave.  To me this means exploiting the point in time where distance meets timing.  Whether that comes after a movement on my opponents part or during the movement itself is another part of the phrase.

As for the quotes directly, I would think it would translate well to staying balanced.  If you are centered (balanced, or rooted) at all times movement in any direction flows naturally and effortlessly.  Being rooted mentally also applies.  Dictates of offensive or defensive action can flow freely in any given situation or part of a fencing phrase when you are "looking" at nothing while noticing everything.

I am likley well off the mark but it was an interesting post that got me thinking a bit...just my 2 cents from reading what you wrote.  Interesting post, thanks.

JS

  Public Discussions  General Babble  Yo Will, chapte...
    
Copyright 2005-2006 Naperville Fencing Club     |    Privacy Statement    |    Terms Of Use